PBM 101: How to Evaluate Your PBM

Is Your PBM Aligned with Your Goals?

Choosing a pharmacy benefit manager (PBM) isn’t just about managing prescription drug costs – it’s about ensuring your PBM operates in a way that aligns with your financial, operational and philosophical goals. A truly aligned PBM works toward the same objectives as you: lowering costs, improving member experiences and delivering better health outcomes. 

When incentives are aligned, everything – from formulary management and network contracting to contract terms and clinical programs – is designed to serve your needs, not the PBM’s. 

So how can you tell if your PBM is truly working in your best interest?

A well-structured PBM can help plan sponsors optimize drug spending over time, protect employee well-being and ensure seamless execution of their benefits plan. However, not all PBMs operate with the same priorities.  

Some emphasize transparency and cost savings for clients, while others maximize their own revenue through hidden fees, retained rebates and upsell strategies. If your PBM isn’t fully transparent about pricing structures, contract terms or revenue streams, it may not be as aligned with your goals as you think. 

Consider these key differences:

Retains price improvements as additional PBM revenue

Passes all price improvements and rebates directly to the plan sponsors

Structures formularies to maximize rebate revenue

Structures formularies based on lowest net cost

Prioritizes high-rebate drugs, even when lower cost options are available

Leverages rebates to offset client costs, not as a driver for decision-making

Focuses on generating more PBM revenue through upselling programs

Focuses on achieving the lowest net cost without upselling

Account teams receive bonuses for upselling services

Account teams prioritize client needs, not sales quotas

Bases programs on their bottom line instead of member outcomes

Reinforces member therapy adherence through clinical engagement programs

Uses vague clinical criteria for claims processing

Adheres to documented audit and clinical guidelines for clear claims processing

Uses complex contract language, often lacking transparency

Uses clear, concise and transparent contract terms

Minimizes access to drug claim level data to obscure actual costs

Provides access to drug claim level data for full visibility to how the benefit is being used

The Navitus Difference: A PBM That Puts Clients First 

At Navitus, we believe true goal alignment means putting clients first – not just in words, but in action. Unlike traditional PBMs that profit from hidden fees and rebate retention, we operate with 100% pass-through and financial transparency. That means we make decisions that align with your organization’s goals, regardless of the potential impact to spread, margins or rebate dollars. Our focus remains on reducing costs, controlling trend over time, improving health outcomes and delivering real value to plan sponsors, health plans and members. 

If your PBM isn’t fully transparent or aligned with your goals, it’s time to explore a better alternative

Contact [email protected] to learn how Navitus can be that solution. 

Stay Informed and Connected

Receive expert insights, healthcare tips, and important updates on pharmacy benefits, drug recalls, and more—straight to your inbox.

Navigating with a trusted partner

Now Available: 9th Annual Drug Trend Report

Our Drug Trend Report provides a clear view of the trends shaping pharmacy benefits today, along with strategies that are delivering real savings without compromising care.

Related blogs

Navigating Healthcare and Improving Outcomes

PBM 101: Understanding Spread Pricing and Its Impact on Plan Costs 

PBM 101: Understanding Spread Pricing and Its Impact on Plan Costs 

There is no shortage of questions surrounding pharmacy benefit business models, especially when medication costs continue to rise. One major area of concern centers on a practice that often goes unnoticed or not understood: spread pricing.  …

Part D Star Ratings Adherence Measures: Enabling Strategic and Focused Support for High-risk Beneficiaries Through the Reporting and Intervention for Stars Excellence (RISE) Program

Part D Star Ratings Adherence Measures: Enabling Strategic and Focused Support for High-risk Beneficiaries Through the Reporting and Intervention for Stars Excellence (RISE) Program

Authors: Wenxuan Cai, PharmD, PhD; Amanda Lee, PharmD; Caitlin Albrecht, PharmD; Maria Basak, CPhT; Casey Herlache; Capriana Hadel, MBA Executive Summary Adherence to key medication classes is a critical metric for evaluating health plan quality and continuous…

PBM 101: How to Evaluate Your PBM

PBM 101: How to Evaluate Your PBM

Choosing a pharmacy benefit manager (PBM) isn’t just about managing prescription drug costs – it’s about ensuring your PBM operates in a way that aligns with your financial, operational and philosophical goals. A truly aligned PBM works toward the same…

Introducing NavitusClear with Costco® Cost Plus Model

Introducing NavitusClear with Costco® Cost Plus Model

NavitusClear is our designation awarded to partners that exemplify the level of transparency in drug pricing we believe should be the industry norm. This solution reflects the shared commitment between Navitus and Costco to address rising drug costs…

PBM 101: Understanding Transparency for Better Pharmacy Benefits

PBM 101: Understanding Transparency for Better Pharmacy Benefits

When it comes to pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs), the word “transparency” gets thrown around a lot. It’s frequently promised, widely discussed and inconsistently delivered.  …

Legal Ease: Key Legislative & Regulatory Updates Impacting Plan Sponsors in 2025

Legal Ease: Key Legislative & Regulatory Updates Impacting Plan Sponsors in 2025

In this overview of our national Legal Ease webinar event, we highlight key federal and state developments shaping the conversation around PBM reform – and what they mean for your clients.  …

Navigating the Drug Supply Chain: What You Need to Know

Navigating the Drug Supply Chain: What You Need to Know

Before a prescription ever reaches a pharmacy counter, it has already moved through a complex ecosystem known as the drug supply chain. From manufacturers and wholesalers to pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) and pharmacies, each entity plays a role in…

Real-world Data Demonstrates Successful Transitions from Humira to Biosimilars

Real-world Data Demonstrates Successful Transitions from Humira to Biosimilars

Authors: Justin Arzt, PharmD; Agata Siwak, PharmD, MSBA; Marnie Wickizer, PharmD, AE-C, CDCES; Ryan Schmidt, PharmD; Robert Topp, RN, PhD; Matt Hustad, PharmD All authors are employees of Navitus Health Solutions. Abstract Adalimumab biosimilar adoption…

PBM 101: Why the Model Matters

PBM 101: Why the Model Matters

In the pharmaceutical and healthcare industry, pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) are conduits of expertise, analytics and savings opportunities, poised to deliver exceptional health care while driving down costs. They coordinate between drug manufacturers,…

previous arrow
next arrow